(This is the set already in my shop)
It was fun, though slightly challenging to come up with 12 different puppets wearing Biblical-looking clothes in neutral colors. There are only so many neutral colors of felt, and so many combinations, before you start feeling like they're all going to look the same! But I had three basic clothing designs, and between those, and the different colors for clothes, hair, beards, etc. I think I managed to come up with 12 unique apostle puppets.
Now I'm just trying to finish up my Thanksgiving puppet set, and our Halloween costumes!